May 9, 2025

On The Calculation of Voume I by Solvej Balle, translated from the Danish by Barbara J.Haveland (“Maybe there’s healing in sentences.”)

My husband, who is a gardener, notices things like this stone that is wrapped with a rope. In Japan, it has a name, sekimori ishi, and it indicates that a path is closed. Or, that visitors should take a different route.

I find it particularly meaningful in light of the way I placed such a stone in my blog. For a long time, it has been closed. Even now I am hesitant to move the boundary stone, uncertain if I’m ready to head down this blogging path again.

Yet, the requests to review books keep coming in, and more surprising than that, to me, is that my blog stats have not significantly changed since the post I last published. Perhaps there is still an interest in what can be found here…

Although I have not joined the International Booker Prize Shadow Jury this year, for the first time in at least eight years, I have been reading the list on my own. I was reluctant to read it under pressure as there is such little time between the announcement of long list and the winner. Instead, I wanted to take my time before submitting scores, and evaluating each book, with fellow shadow members so that we could arrive at a decision as to our winner. 

This year’s short list is not disappointing. I have read all but one, and I would like to share my thoughts on each as we draw closer to learning which book is the winner on May 20, 2025. Let’s begin with On The Calculation of Volume I by Solvej Balle. 

The premise is relatively simple; the narrator relives the same day in her life over and over and over for a year. The end.

But, when thinking about it, I find much deeper applications. For example, couldn’t that scenario depict the way that we are stuck in our lives? We don’t know how we got somewhere, and we often don’t know how to escape. Certainly I have felt that I make the same mistakes, repeat the same routine, relive the same sorrows over and over and over.

Most poignant to me is when she speaks of writing, for it is a similar passion of mine:

I am sitting at a table with a pile of paper in front of me on which I have written that it is the 18th of November and that my name is Tara Selter. I feel as if I am no longer alone. As if someone is listening. My days have not been lost to oblivion. They exist. My days exist in my pile of paper, they have not been erased during the night, the paper remembers…Maybe there’s healing in sentences.” (p. 84)

Of course, this will probably not be an aspect of the book on which most readers focus. But, I am fascinated by the power of writing, the power of words, as a shelter in life’s storm. Can you relate?

13 comments:

  1. I'm happy to see a post from you! You have been missed and I hope that you will return at least from time to time to visit with us. Just know that you are thought about and remembered and missed. Take care, friend!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I’ve missed you, too, Kay. I’m planning on being back, at least from time to time if not more frequently. It’s lonesome not talking about literature with my friends.

      Delete
  2. Yay, glad to see you commenting on the shortlist! And I completely understand about the pressure. I did quite like this one in a quiet, reflective sort of way, but I did not love it. It did not create big waves in my soul, if that doesn't sound too pretentious.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I’m thinking you’re a part of the short list again this year, right, Marina? While I miss the conversation, and the Zoom meetings, during which we discussed the nominations, I just couldn’t face the time crunch. I am such a slow reader, and I needed to absorb these at my own pace as it is some of the richest reading I do all year.

      Overall, I think this year does not disappoint, at least in ways I can previously recall…Iraqi Christ, I’m looking at you. Yet I can see a struggle to connect with this book. For example, if it’s the same day for Tara, isn’t it the same day for everyone else, too? But, I try not to get caught up in technicalities, as I suspend my disbelief and try to catch a deeper meaning. I’m looking forward to continuing the series, because clearly, this is not a stand alone book, and therefore, should it win? (My opinion is no.)

      Delete
  3. M, so happy to read this post. And just know that there will always be an interest in your blog posts - whether they are posted weekly or once in a blue moon:) As for this book you've mentioned, I've seen it everywhere lately. It's a series, right? I don't know much about them, but definitely sounds like an interesting read. I've added it to my TBR list. Wishing you the best my friend. xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nadia, you are one of the most supportive and encouraging friends I have, both within the blog world and without. Thank you for that.

      I suppose many readers who are diving into this year’s International Booker Prize are reviewing the short list, hence your observation of this on social media and blogs. It is a very short read, and quite fascinating, but as I suggested to Marina above, I think it needs reading more than Volume 1 to fully envision what Balle is getting at.

      Delete
  4. Oh, how wonderful to see your post today! I hope you and your husband are doing well. I've missed you. Take good care, Meredith!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How do you keep track of who has posted when, Lesley? I remember trying Feedly after Google Reader (remember those days?!), but I’d love to know you system. Thanks for visiting straight away with a warm welcome. 🥰

      Delete
    2. I use Feedly. I check it once a day (or so), which works well for me. I think I have one or two blogs that I get notified via email whenever there's a new post, but I like Feedly quite well.

      Delete
  5. Welcome back!

    I definitely got caught up in the technicalities of Sad Groundhog Day, because so much space was devoted to the technicalities. I loved the bit about the diminishing supply of her favorite chocolate at the grocery store.

    It is such a sad little book. I guess it is becoming a sad big book.

    Feedly has always worked perfectly for me as a Google Reader replacement.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So many technicalities! I was tempted to go buy an orange flavored dark chocolate bar myself. Might I recommend Lindt?

      However, I liked the bigger picture better. I have four pages of quotes I copied down in my commonplace book, for such a little book that surely is a lot! But I was captured by the exploration of her self, deliberately spaced here, and her life. I felt that the book stood for so much more than the (non) passage of time…I didn’t want to bore people with several copied quotes, but who knows? Maybe I will in another post because they don’t bore me.

      Thanks for recommending Feedly, and confirming Lesley’s choice.

      Delete
  6. I also use Feedly which is how I spotted your post and can recommend it if you feel so inclined.

    Paula @Book Jotter said her post last week "This, to me, is what makes our small but steadfast community such great fun and excellent company. We are always there to encourage or commiserate, discuss and recommend, sometimes picking each other up off the library floor after a deeply discombobulating DNF and, most importantly, we amuse and distract each other in a positive way no matter what is happening in the world."

    Judging by the comments she got, we all agree. We've all known each for such a long time now as book-friends, and lilke irl friends, people come and ago, drop off for a bit, and maybe come back. But when they do we just pick up like there was no time apart at all. Welcome back in whatever way you feel comfortable.

    I've spoken to quite a few customers at work and read a lot of comments about this book - most people seem to be a bit 'meh' about this book, but I'm with you - I feel like I underlined half the book. It spoke to me and I'm desperate to find out where Balle takes us. There's the existential angle which always appeals to me, but also the 'rules' of this particular time slip world - why does she consume all the orange chocolate and bread but when she picks up the flowerpot that has fallen over, it returns to being upturned when she wakes up again?

    ReplyDelete
  7. AnonymousMay 19, 2025

    Sylvie Meignan
    Thank you for your thoughts on THE CALCULATION OF VOLUME 1, I found it in French, there are more volumes coming. Will let you know my thoughts when finish reading. For now I am reading a French novel, a court hearing: LA JURÉ by Claire Jéhanno, Prix des lecteurs.
    At 1 year of 80 I rather read than continue my blog, I am on Instagram.
    Have a blessed day 💗🌺

    ReplyDelete